Never Again Without You: A Radical Paradigm Shift in Poverty Research
In May, ATD Fourth World will announce the results of a major international research project on “Determining the Dimensions of Poverty and How to Measure Them”. This research, conducted in partnership with Oxford University, includes perspectives from people who live in poverty in each of the six countries studied.
Elena Lasida, author of this article, is a professor at the Catholic University of Paris and co-facilitator of the French national research team for the international project.
Poverty has increasingly become a focus of social struggle in our world. Reducing and eliminating poverty are usually included in the objectives of each country’s political programmes. Since 2000, this is also true of the United Nations Development Agenda. It was a great achievement to define what was initially called the “Millennium Development Goals” and from 2015 onwards, the “Sustainable Development Goals“. For the first time, the international community set itself quantified targets to reduce poverty at the global level. The joint definition of these goals has freed up resources and supported poverty reduction policies on a larger scale. This is welcome news indeed.
Paradoxically, this good news has had a negative effect:
the aim of reducing poverty has reinforced the reduction of “the poor” to the category of “object”. Poverty is becoming more visible in statistics and policies, which makes it possible for anti-poverty programmes to be more effective. But at the same time, this objectification of poverty makes the people enduring it less visible.
Above all, we see what is lacking: people living in poverty lack food, housing, clothing, work, health care, training, etc. And we see less and less the person living in poverty with all the complexity associated with human life, marked by needs to be met but also by skills to be deployed. The subject becomes an object.
Ending the Objectification of Poverty
Since it was founded, the International Movement ATD Fourth World has been working to counteract this objectification of poverty. Its members are convinced that efforts to overcome poverty must be undertaken with people in poverty and not for them. ATD Fourth World was launched in 1957 in France, at the emergency housing camp of Noisy-le-Grand, starting from a strong intuition that Joseph Wresinski had that would change the public view of people living in poverty. He found himself confronted, not with individual social cases, but with a people whose members had the same way of dealing with deprivation. The same anxiety about eviction and placement of children in foster care, and the same experience of underemployment and assistance.
According to Wresinski, the only way to overcome poverty is to restore the dignity of this people, to break the inevitability of poverty being transmitted from one generation to the next, and to shatter the belief that people living in poverty are responsible for their situation: “All those who have helped people in poverty to advance, first freed them from themselves. They believed in them and convinced them that they were not guilty of the suffering that history had bequeathed them.” (Les pauvres sont l’Eglise [The Poor Are the Church], interview with Gilles Anouil, Cerf, 2016, p.107)
Many things are done in the name of people living in poverty and of their suffering, often resulting in violence being added to violence. With Wresinski, we change our view on poverty, which is no longer perceived as a natural law, but as a dehumanizing injustice. Any anti-poverty policy must then come from and be conceived with the people who live in poverty. They are not only beneficiaries of charity; they become providers of riches as soon as they are given the opportunity to speak. In public statements, they speak often of the anguish of being on the street and the fear of having their children taken away. This says something very valuable: “The family is the only refuge when everything else is missing; only there, is there still someone to welcome you; only there, you are still someone.” (Anouil p.28)
Research Team Includes People in Poverty
How can we take into account the specific knowledge of people experiencing extreme poverty and rethink anti-poverty policies derived from their knowledge? To move forward in this direction, ATD Fourth World has launched a remarkable project: to consider the person experiencing poverty as a “researcher” who can contribute to creating knowledge about poverty. This seems like madness in a world where only academics are recognized as keepers and creators of knowledge. But we know that only those who dare can change the world. This daring took the form of a series of unlikely encounters.
First, ATD Fourth World partnered with an indisputable player in the academic world, Oxford University, guaranteeing the scientific dimension of the approach. Thus the world of activism and the world of theory found themselves working together. This created an unlikely encounter between the logic of effective action and that of complex reality.
Second, since knowledge always aims to be universal, ATD Fourth World wanted to give this research an international dimension. Six research groups, one in each of six countries, are working on the same project. It involves three northern countries: England, France, and the United States; and three southern countries: Bangladesh, Tanzania, and Bolivia — the global north and the global south, with very different realities of poverty and very unequal research resources, coming together in an unlikely meeting.
Merging Knowledge Approach to Research
Finally, the working method is based on an approach that ATD Fourth World has been gradually implementing and practicing in its Fourth World people’s university: the merging of knowledge. This entails another unlikely encounter between three different sources of knowledge: the knowledge resulting from the experience of poverty; the knowledge generated by professional action to support and assist people experiencing poverty; and the knowledge derived from studying poverty at the academic level.
The approach based on the merging of knowledge reverses three major principles of scientific research in general and research on poverty in particular. First, the object becomes a subject: people living in poverty regain their status as persons. Even more, they become actors and not only victims of poverty. Second, the resource becomes a source: poverty is not reduced to data to be collected in the field; it is conceived as an experience that provides unique and essential knowledge to overcome it. Finally, the dynamic of bringing together different kinds of knowledge results in reciprocal learning. In the merging of knowledge, we do not put the different forms of knowledge in competition; we “learn to learn” from the knowledge of the other.
It is unclear whether this approach will produce more effective tools to overcome poverty. But regardless of its outcome, it already brings about a radical paradigm shift; namely, learning to say to the “beneficiaries” of social action: “Never again without you”.
In France, the following organizations are working in partnership to conduct the dimensions of the poverty research project:
- ATD Fourth World
- Catholic Institute of Paris
- Secours Catholique – Caritas France
- Three Cities Social Centre in Poitiers.
The original article in Portuguese appeared on 3 December on the website of Jesuits of Portugal – https://pontosj.pt/especial/sem-vos-nunca-mais/